Tragedy in the Commons: Former Members of Parliament Speak Out About Canada’s Failing Democracy

Tragedy in the Commons
Tragedy in the Commons

The summer edition of The Catalyst, publication of Citizens for Public Justice, has published a number of books reviews, including mine of a book by Alison Loat and Michael MacMillan, who lead an organization called Samara. Other books reviewed in this issue include those by ecologist Wendell Berry, Naomi Klein and John Ralston Saul and I encourage you to go The Catalyst  website and to read them. Please find below my review below.

Alison Loat and Michael MacMillan run a think tank called Samara, dedicated to increasing the level of political participation in Canada. That’s a steep hill to climb. Turnout for the federal election in 2011 was 61 per cent. Prior to 1993, turnout usually varied between 70 and 80 per cent. Canada is free and democratic when compared to many other countries, but opinion polls exhibit a deep dissatisfaction with our politics and politicians.

The authors decided that former MPs would be the best people to ask about what might be done to improve Canadian politics. They interviewed 80 former MPs, representing all five parties, who had served between 2004 and 2011. Many poured out their frustrations in two-to-three hour interviews.

Oddly and unconvincingly, most identified themselves as outsiders who had never intended to run for office but were reluctantly convinced to do so. A second common theme was their frustration over the controlling influence exerted by their parties and leaders, beginning with their nominations and proceeding to their time in Parliament.

The authors indicate, however, that when they asked MPs what could be done to change the practice of politics for the better most responded with “mere tweaks.” Only a few suggested any institutional reforms and just two recommended electoral reform or proportional representation. It would have been interesting to know how MPs believe they might best work for the necessary change on issues such as poverty, climate change, and the rights of Indigenous peoples. Yet there is virtually no mention of that by the MPs, at least none that is recorded in this book.

There are social movements and community leaders pushing our lawmakers to work for justice, equity, and a planet that can be sustained. Perhaps it is they who should be asked what can be done to change politics for the better.

Tragedy in the Commons: Former Members of Parliament Speak Out About Canada’s Failing Democracy, Alison Loat and Michael MacMillan, Vintage Canada, 2015

One thought on “Tragedy in the Commons: Former Members of Parliament Speak Out About Canada’s Failing Democracy

Add yours

  1. I’m afraid that any chance of improvement in Canadian democracy and parliamentary improvement has become a fading dream with the likes of Harper as Prime Minister. His cynicism in talking about rules after robo calls were made into opponents’ constituencies, (calls like I received telling me that members of a constituency review committee were gerrymandering) and now planning for and calling an election to start early, shows us what we are up against in this country.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: